Reality Checking Government promises on increasing security in Railways

The BJP federal government published an infographic on 48-months portal that makes 3 claims about increasing protection in Indian Railways, in other words., reducing railroad accidents & elimination of Unmanned Level Crossings. This article is a fact check for the claims.

The BJP federal government published an infographic regarding the 48-months portal which makes 3 statements about enhancing protection in Indian Railways. This article is a fact check of the claims.improving Safety in Railways_infographic

Have actually accidents in Railways decreased during current federal government?
The initial claim is that 2017-18 could be the is the best ever before 12 months of safety record for the railways and less than 100 accidents were recorded because year. The claim in addition states that 118 accidents had been taped in 2013-14 whereas only 73 accidents had been taped in 2017-18.

As per the definition of Indian Railways, the term ‘accident’ envelopes a wide spectrum of occurrences with or without significant impact on the system. Having said that, Consequential train accidents feature mishaps with severe repercussion regarding reduced person life or damage, problems for railroad home or interruption to rail traffic of laid straight down limit levels and values. These types of consequential train accidents feature collisions, derailments, fire or surge in trains, roadway automobiles colliding with trains at degree crossings, and certain specified forms of ‘miscellaneous’ train mishaps. To put it differently, only a few accidents/incidents concerning trains or at amount crossings are counted as consequential train accidents. The data discussed in claim is consequential train accidents that often cover the majority of the serious accidents.

In accordance with the data available in the yearly statistical book & the season guide of this Indian Railways, there have been 118 consequential train accidents around 2013-14 and 73 such accidents around 2017-18.  While these numbers are real, this can be only half the story. The sheer number of consequential train accidents being declining continuously since 2003-04 excluding 2014-15 once the amount of accidents increased greatly set alongside the previous 12 months. It continues to be to be noticed whether this reducing trend continues into the years into the future.improving protection in Railways_number of consequential accidents in an yearThe information additionally demonstrates that the entire year 2016-17 saw the highest quantity of fatalities in 7 years when 238 people lost their particular life although the quantity of accidents paid down to 104.

Claim: 2017-18 could be the is the best ever before 12 months of security record for the railways much less than 100 accidents were recorded for the reason that 12 months.

Reality: there have been 118 consequential train accidents in the year 2013-14 and 73 these types of accidents around 2017-18.  While these numbers tend to be TRUE, this really is just half the storyline. How many consequential train accidents happen decreasing since 2003-04 except for 2014-15 if the wide range of accidents increased sharply set alongside the previous 12 months.

What number of unmanned amount crossings being eliminated?
The second claim usually 5,469 unmanned amount crossings had been eliminated plus the normal pace of elimination is 20percent significantly more than that of 2009-14.

As mentioned in an answer in the Lok Sabha, ‘as on 01st April 2018,, there were 5792 unmanned level crossings (UMLCs) from which 3479 were on Broad Gauge (BG), 1135 on Meter Gauge (MG) and 1178 on narrow-gauge (NG).’

Based on information collated through the answers to Lok Sabha concerns 5443, 1001 & 1121 and answer to Rajya Sabha question 4636,  these is observed concerning the removal of unmanned level crossings each year. During UPA-2 (2009-14), an overall total of 5687 UMLCs were eradicated, typically 1137 per year. Throughout the existing federal government, an overall total of 5469 UMLCs had been eradicated during 2014-18, about 1367 annually.It does work your typical range UMLCs removed annually during the current government is 20% above just what were eliminated during UPA-2 (2009-14). Furthermore true that a complete of 5469 UMLCs had been eliminated between 2014-15 and 2017-18.

Claim: 5,469 unmanned amount crossings had been eliminated together with typical speed of eradication is 20% a lot more than compared to 2009-14.

Reality: During UPA-2 (2009-14), a complete of 5687 UMLCs had been eradicated, typically 1137 per year. Through the current government, an overall total of 5469 UMLCs were eliminated during 2014-18, typically 1367 a year. It is true your typical number of UMLCs eliminated annually during the present federal government is 20% above what were eradicated during UPA-2 (2009-14). It is also correct that a total of 5469 UMLCs had been eradicated between 2014-15 and 2017-18. Thus the claim is ACCURATE.

How about complete removal of UMLCs?
The next claim usually, ‘all unmanned level crossings on broad gauge tracks targeted for elimination by 2020.’

Under Mission Zero accident, it had been announced to get rid of all unmanned amount crossings (UMLCs) over broad-gauge system in a phased way’ as mentioned is a Lok Sabha answer in February 2017.   According to an answer offered inside Lok Sabha in December 2018, ‘Elimination of UMLCs has-been a premier priority for Railways as amount crossings are a safety risk both for train and road users much more for road users. As on 01st April 2014,  there have been 8948 UMLCs on BG. Its submitted that most UMLCs on BG have already been eliminated except 28 UMLCs which have been in the pipeline become eliminated by closing, merger, subway and manning.’

But this assertion by the government is pretty astonishing since there were 3479 UMLCs on BG by 01st April 2018 so that as per government’s admission into the Lok Sabha, just 28 such UMLCs aren’t eradicated however. This could signify over 3400 UMLCs on BG were eradicated between April & December 2018, more than twice as much quantity eradicated inside whole year of 2017-18. Ergo one needs to hold back and determine the numbers for your 12 months of 2018-19.

Another response in the Lok Sabha states that,  ‘It could be the endeavour of Railways  to get rid of all unmanned degree crossings in a phased fashion by either of following; 

  • Closure – shutting unmanned amount crossings having NIL/ negligible Train car device (TVU).
  • Merger – Merger of unmanned level crossing gate to close by manned/unmanned amount crossing or subway/Road Under Bridge (RUB)/Road Over Bridge (ROB) by construction of diversion roadway.
  • Provision of Subways/RUBs.
  • Manning- Manning of unmanned level crossings which cannot be eliminated by preceding means.’

Claim: All unmanned degree crossings on broad-gauge paths targeted for reduction by 2020.

Fact: depending on government’s response in the Lok Sabha in December 2018, all UMLCs on BG have been eliminated except 28 UMLCs. Hence, the claim continues to be UNVERIFIED as all UMLCs on BG tend to be geared to be eradicated by 2020.

This tale is a component of a more substantial series regarding 4-years associated with the Modi federal government. This series has-been made possible utilizing the flash grant regarding the Overseas truth Checking system (IFCN). Browse the remaining tales in this show here

The post reality Checking Government claims on increasing protection in Railways showed up first on FACTLY.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

div#stuning-header .dfd-stuning-header-bg-container {background-image: url(;background-size: cover;background-position: center center;background-attachment: scroll;background-repeat: no-repeat;}#stuning-header {min-height: 500px;}
Subscribe To Our Newsletter
Be the first to get latest updates and exclusive content on Workplace Safety & Health straight to your email inbox.
Stay Updated
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.
*We don’t share your personal info with anyone. Check out our Privacy Policy for more information